Let’s ask - albeit fraught with problems and complications galore, but was there really any other option available to Israel but to move into Gaza? Well, they could never have left in the first place or, once gone, the residents could have exploited that opportunity in a positive way rather than enabling the rise to power of an Islamist terror group whose stated and practically sole purpose is the utter destruction of Israel - that would have helped.
But things being what they are, was there really any way to avoid what has happened? Seeing as how if Israel had had prior knowledge of how extensive and sophisticated and therefore how absolute a threat the terror tunnels were that that
in and of itself would have been just cause for entering Gaza regardless of the thousands of missiles and Hamas’ clear intention to cross a line that Israel could not ignore so as to happily martyr their people for the myopic and dumb as dirt world media - I really don't see how anyone could think Israel had a choice here: the existence of the tunnels makes that clear - I mean of course I see how anti-Semites and those who tend to hate Israel as a proxy for hating America and of course liberals in general who as a rule are quite addled when it comes to these things would be able to convince themselves about the viability of ‘other options’ - but for any objective, rational, clear thinking person determined not to cower before the unpleasant facts it’s pretty hard to see how Israel had any choice but to do what its done.
The only thing that
possibly could have convinced Israel to forbear the aggression from Hamas would have been a firm, an
unequivocal commitment from Obama regarding both Israel’s security needs and America’s intention to back that commitment up fully, even with action on the ground if need be -
and on top of that a crystal clear statement challenging the legitimacy of Hamas as a political entity worthy of respect - but there’s not an American ally left in the world who feels they can trust Obama in such a fundamental way - when it comes to Israel what you get from Obama are gestures and platitudes - read between the lines of his words and actions and what you see is a default liberal hubris that is hostile to Israel and naively indulgent of Islamism - like most of the liberal elite he sees Israel as the main problem in the region and not the dysfunctional extremism of Islamist polities - I mean, Kerry and Obama didn't even raise much of a fuss when Fatah and Hamas announced a unity gov't, with Kerry even saying he could work with such a thing - just read
this article on Hamas’ ‘covenant’ to get a good idea why such an egregious betrayal of Israel and common sense in general as that from the Obama administration would cause any sane Israeli not to trust it when it comes to the hardcore facts of Israel’s survival. Netanyahu may have to smile for the cameras and tolerate Obama - but trust him to do what's right when push comes to shove? My guess is he stopped doing that a long time ago.
[actually the default liberal thinking on Israel was that
conservatives in Israel were the problem and that someone like Livni could make peace - but when it comes to security issues left and right have closed ranks in Israel - most Israelis now believe that the only peace the Palestinians are interested in is one that explicitly or implicitly involves the death of Israel, and with 'world opinion' actively or by implication enabling that sentiment, most Israelis would hold that when it comes to an obscenity like Hamas you only have two choices: fight or surrender - which is why support for this war is huge in Israel. Of course these people understand that the war feeds the anti-Israel narrative - but that only matters if you believe Palestinians are sincerely interested in a peace deal that recognizes Israel's right to exist. This is why I say
unequivocal American support for Israel is essential because anything that looks hesitant or reluctant or ambivalent or sophistic ends up rewarding the tactics of Hamas et al and guarantees that eventually Israel will have no choice but to act - because, as said, the only other choice is surrender. Obama has acted all along as if he could use the dubious leverage of 'world opinion' to force Israel into making unwise compromises - I've said all along that that was misguided and would only make a modicum of sense if the Palestinians, and quite frankly the Muslim world in general, were actually serious about defending Israel's right to exist - otherwise you're just backing Israel into a corner from which eventually they'll have
no choice but to fight back from]
[a corollary not yet raised by anyone far as I know: did Fatah know about how extensive the Hamas tunnel system was? If so and said nothing to Israel that would make them complicit in terror acts against Israel - you can argue that
of course they wouldn't have said anything if they knew - but think about it: if Fatah was actually serious about making peace with Israel, what better way to build trust than to reveal intel on the tunnel system? And on the contrary, if the peace negotiations were nothing but a charade playing off of the gullible idiocy of Kerry in order to drive negative opinions of Israel, what better way to make that clear than to keep hidden such a serious threat?]